Discussion about this post

User's avatar
bruce kleinman's avatar

I don't know. Different values. Different cultures. Here is a guy - Jeff Pearlman - who invests time, effort ... essentially his whole being in sorta a hagiography project ... about - in the long run - a trivial unimportant person. Really? And I'm supposed to care? Jeff Pearlman should get a life. Particularly since Dick Schaaf apparently already walked this path.

As far as the books stores being brave and noble. Count me skeptical. I'm wondering if the subject was Nick Sabin, and ole Nick called in a similar vein, would the bookstores be so noble in standing up for the First? Count me doubtful.

Expand full comment
David Harris's avatar

I think we can all stand against censorship, but Jeff Pearlman is one of the last writers I will ever feel sorry for. I do not share your high opinion of his work. He takes on excellent subjects, and he is to be given some credit for choosing them, but I do not think he does them justice. I've read three of his works, and I haven't read any of Bob Woodward's, but he is like Woodward in that, as an athlete, you'd be a fool to ever authorize his reporting of you. (Politicians are reminded that, when consenting to a Woodward interview, they will not win. He is not to be spun. The one exception I can think of with Pearlman is Troy Aikman.) Michael Lewis's original reservation about Pearlman's book about the '86 Mets has stood up as Pearlman has built his oeuvre: you didn't come away liking any of the players on the team. That can't be reality. Pearlman may say he's reporting the truth, and that the portraits are balanced, but the profiles he writes are deeply troubling. One example would be Jerry Jones. Seemed like a monster in the book Pearlman wrote about the Cowboys, but I watched a documentary with him in it, and I don't think Pearlman got the essence of the man. Beyond this, Pearlman's analytical abilities, statistical and otherwise, are simply poor. Going chapter by chapter, I can eviscerate his work, and there are more problems in reasoning than one can name. Then the Cowboys book featured a couple of grating analogies on every page. They were showy but distracting. I wish the sports biography market were bigger, and the considerable attention given to Pearlman's work was shifted to more deserving authors.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts